Digital Cameras, Pro's and Cons
Do I really want a digital camera?
When people find out that I have a digital camera they often ask me how good
are they and is it worth them getting one, this is my attempt at answering that
question.
Many people naturally think that digital is good, its something that the
consumer industry has been carefully nurturing for at least the last 15 or 20
years. What digital does give you is a guaranteed quality, you don't get any
worse than that specified but you don't get any better either, this is as true
with digital photography as it is with music CD's or telephone connections.
With digital photography the primary measure of quality that we
use is resolution (although you can use number of colors too) and using that
measure the quality that you get is almost certainly many times
worse that what you are used to even with a cheap throw
away camera.
So given that the resolution of a digital camera is awful why do I and many
others have one? The answer is quite simple, my pictures are always destined
for the computer screen and since the resolution of a computer screen is awful
too, the lack of resolution is less of an issue. What does however become an
issue is the process of getting a picture from the lense of my camera onto the
computer and it is here that the digital camera excels. Its also cheaper per
photo since it doesn't require you go pay someone to get them developed.
Or in summary:
Unless your pictures are destined for a
computer screen (or you are prepared to spend a lot of money) don't even
think about getting a digital camera
Considerations when buying a digital camera
There are an increasing number of digital cameras now on the market and the
price range is enormous. To a large extent you get what you pay for, and
that can be quite a bit. The manufacturers also seem to have produced
cameras in every shape imaginable, not all of which are particularly suitable
for the job. Considering this my first rule in buying
a digital camera is to try it out first, in the UK
Jessops will generally let you do this
and will have the kit arranged so you can, most other traditional camera
shops will too. Avoid consumer electronics stores as your first visit, in
general they don't know enough about cameras to be able to help properly,
you may however want to revisit one later if you find a cheap price.
When considering features the rules for a traditional camera still apply, there
are however several features unique to digital cameras which need to be
considered and several features from a traditional camera that have added
value in a digital camera.
Features unique to a digital camera
- Storage (size),
this is usually quoted as a combination of raw megabytes
and the number of pictures that can be stored. Be careful of the second figure,
this is usually calculated using the lowest resolution picture, always ask how
many pictures it can store when used at the highest resolution only this may
be up to 50 times fewer than at the lowest resoltion. Both CompactFlash and
SmartMedia come in many sizes, so even if you camera comes without much
memory you can usually increase it.
- Storage (media),
this is the digital camera's equivilent of film, its a race between
many options and the industry doesn't seem to be standardizing on any
particular one. Storage cards are considerably more expensive than
film, however they can be reused again and again. The most common
formats seem to be SmartMedia and CompactFlash, there isn't much
between them, although CompactFlash is a little larger, a little more
robust, and seem to be available in larger capacities. Remember generally
you will need enough storage so you can keep your pictures until you
transfer them onto your computer.
- Picture screen,
picture screens are nice but they can use up lots of battery, early
digital cameras with picture screens were notorious for only letting
you take one or two pictures before the picture screen eat all the
battery. Avoid cameras
that have a screen, and no viewfinder, you tend to end up holding the
camera a long way from your body, and this causes extra camera shake.
- Resolution,
in general the higher the resolution the better. Higher resolution
gives you bigger pictures and thus more room for cropping. If you need
to reduce the size of the picture at a later date most packages can do
this without affecting the picture dramatically. Resolution is
normally measured in megapixels, at around 3 or 4 megapixels a picture
printed at normal holiday snap size is almost as good as that taken
from a normal camera.
- Picture storage speed,
some cameras are rather slow at storing large
images and in general you can't take one photo until the previous one is
stored. Many cameras now have an extra area of memory in order to allow you
to take many pictures quickly without having to wait for each one to be stored.
- Battery,
although traditional cameras often have a battery, its considerably
more important in a digital camera. The act of actually taking a photo
use quite a lot of current, especially with the flash on, this makes cheap
and rechargeable batteries run out quickly, however good batteries will
generally last quite a while. Picture screens can also use
lots of battery, especially if used in "video" mode to view the shot before
you've actually taken it. Also be careful of cameras that take non-standard
batteries, or need rechargers. Rechargeable batteries tend to
have a longer life, however generally you can't pop into the nearest
newsagents and replace them. On a long holiday remember to take your
charger with you, and an international adapter if needbe.
Traditional Features that are especially useful
- Zoom,
framing is especially important in digital photography since you
can't blow up part of a picture after having taken it, without it looking
pixelly and any cropping is lost picture. A zoom allows you to
blow the picture up before taking it, so that it almost fills the
frame, reducing cropping and removing the need to blow the picture up.
In digital photography zooms come in two flavours, optical and digital. An
optical zoom uses a traditional zoom lense before the picture is digitized,
while a digital zoom takes the picture normally and then blows it up digitally.
In practice most digital zooms simply take the picture at the highest
resolution and crop the picture to half the size. You can spot this when the
camera says that the digital zoom doesn't work in the highest resoluton.
- SLR (single lense reflex).
These are very expensive, however they are what all professionals use. Lenses
can be interchanged, filters can be used, and the control of the camera is far
better.
Considerations when taking a photo
Avoid
- Wide landscape shots,
they tend to need a lot of resolution.
- Shots where detail at a distance is important.
I have a classic shot of trafalgar square being taken over by a mob.
The main feature was intended to be a banner drapped over Canada House. However
the banner is further enough away that you can't actually read what it says.
- Shots with lots of people in them.
The classic school class photograph doesn't work since when you look at it
closely you sometimes can't work out who anybody is.
Ensure you
- Frame the shot properly, get the person or
object you are photographing filling the frame as much as you can, this may
mean you need to get closer. If photographing a person its often better to
tip the camera 90 degrees and take a portrait shot rather than a landscape
one.
- Follow the normal photography rules, the
optics of a digital camera are no different from a regular camera, most of
the normal rules of photography still apply.
A picture screen is very good at checking the
framing of the shot, ensuring you didn't get your finger over the lense
and making sure someone didn't walk in front of the camera. However if often
doesn't show up camera shake and under or over exposure.
Using a photo on the web
Digital camera photos may be lacking in resolution, but the pictures they
take are still in general far too large for the average 56k modem connection.
To solve this
- Crop your photo, so that it only contains what
you are interested in.
- Reduce the resolution of the picture so that it
loads faster, this is much more important if the picture is to be inline image.
- Use a link not the photo. It is often better to
display a just a link or a thumbnail of a picture with a link to the full size
picture rather than the full picture directly.
- Tell your viewers how big a photo is, especially
if its to be downloaded via a link.
Its also worth noting
- A picture taken digitally can be digitally
enhanced, however major changes will make the photo look wrong. I
find sharpening the picture,
and minor changes in contrast to be particularlly effective. Trying to edit
out parts of picture that shouldn't be there generally doesn't work.
- Pictures generally don't make good backgrounds,
unless they are mainly one color, or you modify them to make them mainly one
color. (You can't read the text on top of them).
- Perform all edits on a copy of the picture,
you might need the original.
- For professional use a watermark is a good idea,
this can be digitally
hidden into the photo, or simply your name printed on the bottom.
- If the picture is not your own check you are allowed
to use it.
- Ask friends before using a picture with them in
it, some people do not like their photos published.
I generally crop my photos, sometimes alter the contrast if the picture is a
bit dull, reduce the resolution, sharpen the picture and then display my
pictures as thumbnails with the real picture available by clicking on the
thumbnail.
Brian Blackmore bnb@looking-glass.org